Mark February 23, 2008 as the ten-year, Cluetrain gut-check presentation. Doc Searls gave a presentation that day in New York, and I just discovered it via his blog post. It's outstanding. It's part history lesson and part updated vision.
Torrents of water have passed under the bridge since Cluetrain was published in January 2000, but sometimes it feels like we're still back in that time. As more marketers have "discovered" social media, it's become more bastardized. As a purists, I'm finding it harder and harder to convince people and companies to use social media in a way that doesn't turn it into another advertising medium.
Doc says it best when commenting about Facebook:
"It's absurd and it's insane and it's also terribly popular...I don't want to knock it for that reason...a lot of people love Facebook...but how much of it actually is bullshit."
"Now you're not just a face. You're a target. And a tool."
"It's still, still about selling eyeballs to advertisers. Welcome to 1997. It's ten year's later and it's the same crap."
Indeed. I checked my own Facebook front page tonight, and what new app did I find right there at the top?
This is what Jesus must have felt like, shouting into a hurricane of years of accepted practices with twelve guys behind him saying "it's cool, it's cool, we got your back, keep shouting, we'll shout too." But the hurricane just got bigger and louder until it blew him over, and the disciples were left to try and make sense of the pieces.
So the first half of Doc's presentation is a bit of a lament about how far we have not come since Cluetrain was published, and being a Cluetrain disciple, my blog post echos that lament. But then Doc goes into a list of his ten "hopes" for the future -- hopes that were implicit in Cluetrain, he said.
My favorite is #7: "Markets will be understood in terms of relationships," which relates to his #8, "We'll be able to manage vendors as least as well as they manage us." This sets up Doc's discussion of VRM -- vendor relationship management, where the customer requests the relationship -- "real relationships between truly consenting parties, whether those relationships are enduring or transitory," Doc says.
"It tests the belief that markets can be truly free and open. And in control by customers as well as vendors. With real relationships, not just coerced agreements we call 'relationships'."
I've been a believer in the Cluetrain philosophy since I read the book in 2001. It's the only reason I've chosen to stay in marketing and public relations. It's because I believe in the power of "real relationships" and the role PR can play in bringing them about between customers and companies.
In December 2004 and again in April 2005 I wrote posts about this subject and offered an extension to Doc's "markets are conversations" meme, which I called the "un-marketing manifesto." It's March 2008, and we're still talking about it. Something tells me we'll be talking about it in 2015 too.
Technorati Tags:
Doc Searls, Cluetrain, VRM